Character vs Supernatural: The Epic Showdown in Storytelling

character vs supernatural
by David Harris // May 15  

In storytelling, the age-old question of character versus the supernatural often arises. How do characters react to supernatural elements, and what does this tension reveal about them? The answer is simple: characters serve as the lens through which readers engage with supernatural events, shaping the narrative’s impact and resonance. This relationship is crucial in various genres, influencing plot development and character growth.

Character Reactions to Supernatural Elements

Characters serve as the heartbeat of any story. Their reactions to supernatural occurrences can define the narrative. For instance, consider a horror novel where the protagonist encounters a ghost. This encounter is not just an event; it’s a critical moment that reveals character depth.

Imagine a skeptical journalist, tasked with uncovering the truth behind a haunted house. When faced with a ghost, the journalist’s disbelief becomes a character flaw. This tension enhances reader investment—it’s one thing to read about spirits; it’s another to witness characters grapple with fear, logic, and disbelief.

The Reluctant Believer

A classic example of character reaction to the supernatural is the ‘reluctant believer’ trope. This character type often begins the story as a skeptic. Over time, their encounters with the supernatural force them to confront their disbelief. For example, in many urban fantasy novels, the main character starts as an ordinary person, often dismissive of magic or otherworldly beings.

Take Harry Dresden from the “Dresden Files.” Initially, he struggles with the supernatural world he inhabits. As he confronts various entities, his journey reveals layers of vulnerability, courage, and ultimately acceptance. The challenge isn’t just the encounter with a spectral foe; it’s about embracing or rejecting the unknown essence of his identity as a wizard.

The Role of the Supernatural in Character Development

Supernatural elements play a pivotal role in shaping characters. These elements force characters to confront their fears, aspirations, and moral dilemmas. The supernatural often acts as a catalyst for character growth and revelation.

Conflict and Motivation

The supernatural can introduce conflict, pushing characters into situations that challenge their beliefs and decisions. In Shakespeare’s “Macbeth,” the witches’ prophecies propel Macbeth into a spiral of ambition and moral decay. The supernatural intensifies his internal struggles, making his eventual downfall all the more tragic.

Consider a character who has survived an encounter with a supernatural being. This experience might haunt them, driving them to become a monster hunter or a psychic medium. This transformation showcases not just their resilience but also their moral compass. The decisions they make in light of their supernatural experiences reflect their evolving character.

Genre Variations: Supernatural in Romance and Horror

The treatment of supernatural elements varies across genres, influencing character dynamics significantly.

Supernatural in Horror

In horror, characters typically face malevolent supernatural beings. These confrontations amplify their flaws and weaknesses. A perfect example is the character archetype of “the final girl” in slasher films. This character often starts as naive or innocent. However, as the story progresses and they face supernatural threats, they evolve into more self-reliant figures.

The character development parallels with the horrors they endure creates a compelling narrative. For instance, in “The Conjuring,” the Warrens assist a family plagued by a demonic entity. The family’s reactions to relentless supernatural horror shape their resilience and unity, presenting a gripping exploration of fear and survival.

Supernatural in Fantasy

In fantasy, characters often navigate between realms, wielding supernatural powers or encountering fantastical beings. The supernatural here broadens their possibilities and provides the tools to grow. Consider Frodo in Tolkien’s “The Lord of the Rings”, who faces magical beings and artifacts that challenge his courage and ethical character. Each encounter influences him, molding him from a simple hobbit into a reluctant hero.

Characters within fantastical settings can also explore their limitations. Think about characters who seek power but must confront the dark consequences of their supernatural associations. This dynamic can create multi-dimensional beings torn between light and darkness.

Themes of Identity and Agency

The intersection of character and the supernatural also raises questions about identity and agency. Characters often experience transformations—literal and metaphorical—as they interact with supernatural forces.

Identity Crisis

The transformation caused by supernatural elements often leads to identity crises. In many stories, characters who gain supernatural abilities must redefine their place in the world. Consider Buffy Summers, the protagonist of Buffy the Vampire Slayer, who grapples with her identity not only as a slayer but also as a friend, daughter, and eventually a role model to her peers.

Her interactions with vampires, demons, and other supernatural elements constantly challenge her understanding of self and purpose. These layers foster a richer character that captures readers’ attention and empathy.

Agency versus Control

Supernatural forces often test characters’ agency. In stories where the supernatural is omnipresent, characters might feel controlled by these elements rather than empowered by their abilities. This theme is prevalent in narratives like “Firestarter” by Stephen King, where the protagonist, Charlie, faces external pressures that manipulate her supernatural talent, raising questions about free will and control.

Characters who reclaim their agency often serve as beacons of hope in darker narratives, impacting the reader’s emotional journey alongside their fictional experience.

The Impact of Supernatural Mindsets

The mindset of characters toward the supernatural can drastically alter the narrative pace and tone. Characters’ willingness to embrace or shun the supernatural affects plot development.

Belief Versus Skepticism

Characters who believe in the supernatural tend to gravitate toward storytelling that embraces mystery and wonder. In contrast, skeptics may repel such forces, leading to tension and conflict. This relationship often dictates whether characters will succeed or succumb to supernatural challenges.

A notable case is the character of Elvira in “The Elvira Mistress of the Dark.” Her belief in her supernatural allure allows her to navigate the bizarre events of her life with a mix of confidence and humor. Conversely, characters who scoff at the supernatural often find themselves in precarious situations, emphasizing the dichotomy between belief and skepticism.

Humor and Supernatural

Humor can also emerge when characters face the absurdity of the supernatural. Tongue-in-cheek narratives often take a lighter approach, blending humor with horror. In works like “Ghostbusters,” characters’ comical interactions with supernatural elements create memorable moments that ease tension while reinforcing character dynamics.

This blend of humor and supernatural themes shapes character relationships, illustrating how perceptions of the supernatural are mirrored in character interactions.

Final Thoughts

The relationship between character and the supernatural provides a rich tapestry for storytelling. Each character’s unique reactions, development, and journey shape the narrative landscape, making it a pivotal element for engaging literature. Whether through moments of revelation, crises of identity, or the exploration of belief and skepticism, characters engage with the supernatural in a way that elevates storytelling to resonate with readers. Embracing the challenge of navigating this complex relationship offers writers endless possibilities for developing dynamic characters that captivate their audiences.

Additional Information

Character and supernatural elements often clash in literature, creating intriguing dynamics that can enhance storytelling. Here are some secrets about how they interact:

  1. Character Development vs. Supernatural Traits: Characters with supernatural abilities often face a unique challenge. Authors must balance these powers with deep character flaws, making them relatable and human despite their extraordinary abilities.
  2. The Role of Vulnerability: Even the most powerful supernatural beings require vulnerability to be compelling. Writers commonly emphasize their weaknesses to add depth and create tension, making readers root for them.
  3. Subversion of Tropes: Many supernatural stories rely on established tropes, like the brooding vampire or the misunderstood witch. Breaking these molds can lead to original characters that surprise and engage audiences.
  4. Character Motivation: Supernatural elements can serve as a tool to highlight characters’ desires and fears. For instance, a character’s desire for power might lead them to make dark choices that ultimately reveal their true nature.
  5. Cultural Context: Supernatural elements often draw from cultural lore. Authors sometimes incorporate lesser-known myths and legends to create depth and authenticity, connecting the characters’ journey to wider traditions.
  6. Symbolism in Powers: The supernatural abilities a character possesses can symbolize their inner struggles or ethical dilemmas. For example, a character who can control fire may wrestle with anger inside, showcasing their emotional journey through their powers.
  7. Foils and Contrast: Characters that embody opposing aspects of the supernatural can enhance conflict and theme. A human character facing off against a supernatural counterpart can shine a light on what it means to be truly human.
  8. Impact on Story Arc: The introduction of supernatural elements can drastically alter the trajectory of a character’s arc. The stakes may rise, forcing characters to confront fears or embrace transformations they hadn’t anticipated.
  9. Character Relationships: Supernatural abilities can complicate or strengthen relationships between characters, creating tension and conflict. Characters must navigate the unique dynamics that arise from one having powers while the other does not.
  10. Transformation Themes: Many stories intertwine character development with supernatural transformations, using these changes to mirror personal growth or identity crises.

Exploring these secrets can deepen the reader’s understanding of character dynamics and the role of the supernatural in storytelling.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs) Related to Character Vs Supernatural

Q. What does “character vs supernatural” mean in storytelling?
A. “Character vs supernatural” is a conflict in stories where a character faces challenges or forces that are beyond the natural world, such as ghosts, monsters, or other supernatural entities.

Q. Can you give an example of a “character vs supernatural” conflict?
A. Sure! A classic example is in the story “Dracula,” where characters battle against the vampire Count Dracula, a supernatural being that preys on them.

Q. What are some common themes in “character vs supernatural” stories?
A. Common themes include fear, survival, the battle between good and evil, and the exploration of life after death.

Q. How do characters typically respond to supernatural forces?
A. Characters might react with fear, determination, curiosity, or skepticism, depending on their personalities and the situation they find themselves in.

Q. Do “character vs supernatural” stories always have a clear resolution?
A. Not always. Some stories may leave the conflict unresolved, emphasizing the ongoing struggle against supernatural elements.

Q. How does the supernatural affect character development?
A. The supernatural often pushes characters to confront their fears, question their beliefs, or prove their strength, leading to significant growth.

Q. What role does setting play in “character vs supernatural” stories?
A. The setting can enhance the supernatural elements, often creating an eerie or otherworldly atmosphere that heightens tension and suspense.

Q. Are there specific genres that commonly feature “character vs supernatural”?
A. Yes, genres like horror, fantasy, and paranormal fiction frequently explore the “character vs supernatural” conflict.

Q. Can humor coexist in a “character vs supernatural” story?
A. Absolutely! Many stories incorporate humor to provide relief from tension, making the characters more relatable amid supernatural chaos.

Q. How can writers effectively portray the supernatural in their stories?
A. Writers can establish clear rules for their supernatural elements, build suspense, and focus on character reactions to make the supernatural feel real and impactful.

Conclusion

In the ongoing debate of character versus supernatural elements in storytelling, both have their unique strengths. Character-driven stories invite readers to connect on an emotional level, while supernatural themes offer escapism and excitement. Ultimately, the best narratives often blend both elements, striking a balance that keeps readers engaged and curious. Whether you’re crafting complex characters or spinning fantastical tales, remember that each approach has its place in the realm of literature. Happy writing!

About the Author

David Harris is a content writer at Adazing with 20 years of experience navigating the ever-evolving worlds of publishing and technology. Equal parts editor, tech enthusiast, and caffeine connoisseur, he’s spent decades turning big ideas into polished prose. As a former Technical Writer for a cloud-based publishing software company and a Ghostwriter of over 60 books, David’s expertise spans technical precision and creative storytelling. At Adazing, he brings a knack for clarity and a love of the written word to every project—while still searching for the keyboard shortcut that refills his coffee.