Anachronism is a term used to describe something that is placed in a time period where it doesn’t belong. This can occur in literature, film, or even everyday conversation. The main problem is that anachronisms can confuse audiences, distract from the work, or even undermine its credibility. The good news? Careful observation helps you recognize anachronisms and turn them into clever advantages.
Table of Contents
What Is Anachronism?
An anachronism occurs when an object, concept, or event is out of its correct chronological order. It’s not just a slip-up; it can be a deliberate tool used by authors and creators to make a point or evoke humor. Anachronisms can be artifacts, language, or even social customs that seem out of place.
For instance, if a character in a historical novel set in the 18th century refers to a smartphone, that’s an obvious anachronism. Smart devices didn’t exist in that timeframe, and their mention ruins the authenticity of the setting. However, anachronisms can also serve a purpose. Shakespeare’s plays contain historical anachronisms that add layers of meaning or humor and connect with audiences.
Types of Anachronism
Anachronisms can manifest in several ways. Here are a few common types:
1. Temporal Anachronisms
These involve an event or item that is clearly from a different time period than the setting. A classic example is a movie depicting Ancient Rome with characters using modern slang. Here, the language clashes with the historical context.
For example, in the film “The Time Machine” (2002), a character uses a digital watch in a scene set in the distant future. This clocks in a temporal anachronism that does not align with the expected technology of the depicted era.
2. Social Anachronisms
These refer to practices or beliefs that are inconsistent with the societal norms of a given time. Imagine a novel set in the Victorian era where women openly discuss and critique gender inequality in a modern fashion. While this can be a mechanism for commentary, it can demand a suspension of disbelief from the audience.
A good example is the character of Elizabeth Bennet in “Pride and Prejudice” by Jane Austen. While Elizabeth challenges societal norms for her time, achieving a level of independence uncommon for women of her era, she still retains a voice that aligns closely with her historical context.
3. Technological Anachronisms
This category deals with the use of modern technology in past settings. Picture a medieval knight wielding a laser sword—a blend that clashes with historical accuracy.
In the popular “Netflix series The Witcher,” Geralt of Rivia uses weapons and armor that align with the fictional medieval timeline, but modern-day weaponry or references would not fit. The portrayal, alongside the mythology, requires careful attention to maintain the illusion of the world.
Real-World Examples of Anachronism
Movies and Television
One of the most famous examples of anachronism is in the film “Back to the Future.” Marty McFly travels back to the 1950s, where he plays rock music on a guitar that doesn’t fit the period, overlapping innovative sounds of the future with the past. While this might appear jarring, it’s a clever narrative choice that helps illustrate the differences between time periods and the development of music.
Another example is in the series “Game of Thrones,” set in a fantastical world drawing heavily from medieval themes. Yet, some characters display modern attitudes toward governance and relationships that would be anachronistic in a setting reminiscent of historical feudalism.
Literature
In literature, authors often deliberately include anachronisms to challenge readers’ expectations. Kurt Vonnegut’s “Slaughterhouse-Five” contains characters who experience time non-linearly. This unconventional narrative structure can lead to anachronisms, but they serve to reflect the protagonist’s trauma and disjointed experiences during World War II.
Another example is in the graphic novel “Watchmen” by Alan Moore, where characters discuss ideas and philosophies that reflect modern issues, although they are set in the 1980s. The clever blending of different timelines prompts readers to reflect on continuity and change.
Using Anachronism Effectively
Crafting Humor
One of the most effective ways to use anachronism is through humor. Comedians and writers can insert modern references into historical settings to create comedic effects. For example, think of a stand-up routine where a Roman gladiator checks his social media profile before entering the arena. It’s not just funny; it also highlights the absurdity of combining drastically different time periods.
Engaging with Themes
Anachronisms can also be used to engage with themes that resonate across time. For instance, when a character in a historical fiction novel expresses modern views on ethics or technology, it allows the reader to ponder how much has really changed. This layered complexity can make the narrative more profound.
Consider the novel “The Last Samurai” by Helen DeWitt, where characters discuss modern philosophy while living in Japan during the Meiji Restoration. The anachronistic elements provide a richer understanding of the characters’ dilemmas and aspirations.
Enhancing Character Development
Characters can be defined or contrasted through their relationship with time. When a character embodies anachronistic traits, it can reveal their personalities, motivations, and ideals. For example, a young person in a historical setting who speaks in contemporary idioms can illustrate their struggle to fit in and identify with a different time.
A prime example is in the play “Romeo and Juliet.” Juliet’s youthful defiance and passionate declarations can be considered anachronistic, as her frustrations mirror issues adolescents grapple with in any era. That relatability allows the audience to connect with her character on a personal level.
Common Pitfalls of Anachronism
Loss of Credibility
One major risk of anachronism is that it can shatter the credibility of the work. If a historical novel features characters casually discussing topics like climate change or virtual reality, it may lead to readers questioning the author’s research and understanding of the setting.
Confusion among Audiences
When anachronisms are not clearly intentional, they can confuse audiences, detracting from the main narrative. Readers or viewers may struggle to keep track of the timeline and the intended messages, weakening their overall experience.
Difficulties in World-Building
In genres like fantasy and science fiction, inconsistent anachronisms can disturb the credibility of world-building. If a fantasy realm contains both medieval knights and contemporary technology without a plausible explanation, the audience may find it difficult to suspend disbelief.
Final Thoughts
Anachronism is a powerful tool for writers and creators when used thoughtfully. From generating humor to exploring deep themes and character development, anachronisms can enrich narratives. However, it is essential to use this tool with a clear understanding of the potential pitfalls to maintain the integrity and engagement of the work. Whether in literature or film, anachronisms offer unique opportunities for creative expression, bringing together disparate timelines for fresh storytelling experiences.
Additional Information
Anachronism adds an intriguing twist to storytelling, often revealing unexpected connections between different time periods.
- The “Unintentional” Anachronism: Many historical fiction authors may include artifacts or technologies that didn’t exist in the time period they’re writing about, but they can sometimes serve a purpose. For example, a character might use a smartphone to create a modern absurdity, offering comic relief or clever commentary on contemporary society.
- Playwrights and Time Bending: Shakespeare was known for his anachronisms. In “Julius Caesar,” the presence of clocks and other Renaissance elements in a Roman setting reflects the playwright’s era, allowing audiences to relate more directly to the characters.
- Historical Figures in Modern Media: Movies and shows like Bill and Ted’s Excellent Adventure or The Time Traveler’s Wife feature famous figures from history interacting with modern characters, which can provide humor and insight into both the past and present.
- Misunderstood Timelines: Some readers erroneously believe that a story set in a historical period must strictly adhere to the timeline. Instead, authors often bend historical facts to emphasize character development or thematic depth, sometimes to enhance relatability.
- Language Evolution: Anachronistic language often slips into historical narratives as modern expressions or slang are used in old settings. This choice aims to engage contemporary audiences, making historical dialogue more accessible.
- Marketing Tactics: Anachronism can also be leveraged in book marketing. Titles like Pride and Prejudice and Zombies use anachronism to catch readers’ attention and create unique niches within genres.
- Cultural Commentary: By placing modern concepts into historical contexts, authors can create sharp critiques of both the past and the present. This juxtaposition allows for deeper discussions of societal norms and practices.
- The Risk of Confusion: While authors may intentionally include anachronisms for effect, overly confusing time shifts can alienate readers. Balancing creativity and clarity keeps the narrative flow smooth and natural.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs) Related to Anachronism Example
Q. What is an anachronism?
A. An anachronism is something that is out of its proper time period, often leading to confusion or humor. For example, if a character in a historical novel uses a smartphone, that’s an anachronism.
Q. Can you give an example of an anachronism in literature?
A. Sure! In Shakespeare’s play “Julius Caesar,” if a character mentions using a microwave, that’s an anachronism because microwaves weren’t invented until centuries later.
Q. Why do writers use anachronisms intentionally?
A. Writers may use anachronisms for comedic effect or to highlight contrasts between different time periods, making a point or engaging their audience more effectively.
Q. What could happen if an author accidentally includes an anachronism?
A. An accidental anachronism can distract readers, lead to confusion, or undermine the credibility of the work, especially in historical fiction.
Q. Are anachronisms more common in film or literature?
A. Anachronisms can be found in both film and literature, but they may be more noticeable in film since visuals often highlight discrepancies more clearly.
Q. How can writers avoid unintentional anachronisms?
A. Writers can conduct thorough research about the time period they are writing about and double-check details to ensure they fit within the historical context.
Q. What is a famous anachronism in movies?
A. In “Braveheart,” actors are seen wearing kilts, which is an anachronism since kilts became popular centuries after the movie’s setting.
Q. Do all readers notice anachronisms?
A. Not all readers notice anachronisms, especially if they are not familiar with the specific time period. However, those who are knowledgeable might find them jarring.
Q. Can an anachronism add to a story’s theme?
A. Yes, an anachronism can underline themes, such as the clash of modern values with traditional ones, enhancing the reader’s understanding of those themes.
Q. Is there a type of fiction where anachronisms are expected?
A. In genres like steampunk or certain types of fantasy, anachronisms are often part of the charm, blending different historical elements to create a unique setting.
Conclusion
Anachronisms are like unexpected guests at a party—they can surprise us, amuse us, or even confuse us. They serve as a reminder that time is a complex tapestry, and sometimes, elements from different eras can intersect in intriguing ways. Whether in literature, film, or art, spotting an anachronism can spark curiosity and encourage us to explore the context and history surrounding it. So, the next time you encounter an anachronism, take a moment to appreciate how it enriches our understanding of the story or message being conveyed. After all, even the most carefully crafted narratives can benefit from a little temporal playfulness.
